Rekey or Replace Your Locks? A Vero Beach Homeowner’s Guide

← Back to the Benson’s Lock Service blog

Quick answer:Rekey a working, compatible lock when you want existing keys to stop working. Replace the hardware when it is damaged, unreliable, incompatible with your needs, or when you want different security features.

Getting the keys to a home does not tell you how many copies are still circulating. For Vero Beach homeowners, reviewing door security belongs on the move-in checklist alongside setting up utilities and checking smoke alarms. The right solution depends on the condition of the locks and who should have access.

What is the difference between rekeying and replacing a lock?

Rekeying changes the key configuration inside a compatible lock cylinder. The outside hardware can remain, but the previous key no longer operates that rekeyed cylinder. Replacement changes the lock hardware itself. Neither choice should be made without checking whether the door closes and latches properly.

When does rekeying make sense?

Consider rekeying after a home purchase, a lost key, or a change in who is authorized to enter. It can preserve hardware you like while resetting access. Ask Benson’s about lock rekeying in Vero Beach and identify every exterior door you want included.

Rekeying one entrance does not change the keys to other doors. Include side entrances, garage entry doors, and any separate keyed deadbolts when you discuss the job. If a smart lock also has a mechanical key, review both the key and its electronic access settings.

When is replacement the better choice?

A new key configuration will not repair a worn mechanism or straighten a misaligned door. Tell the locksmith if the key sticks, the bolt only moves when you lift the door, or the lock has visible damage. A lock installation and repair assessment can identify whether the problem is in the hardware, door, or frame.

Is rekeying cheaper than replacing locks?

Rekeying can cost less when suitable hardware can be retained. The total depends on the number of cylinders, their condition, compatibility, key requirements, and whether service is in the shop or at your property. Compare complete quotes rather than a single advertised starting price.

What should you prepare before calling?

• Count the doors and keyed cylinders.
• Photograph the hardware and any brand markings.
• Explain whether you have working keys.
• Decide how many new keys you need.
• Ask what ownership or authorization documents to provide.

Frequently asked questions

For more background, see Schlage’s guidance on professional rekeying. For help with your own doors, explore Benson’s residential locksmith services.

Get help from Benson’s Lock Service

Discuss your project with the team in Vero Beach. Call 772-567-5968 or request a locksmith quote.